Very Grand Rounds

Very Grand Rounds

Guess where I was this week?

I was invited by the faculty of the University of Michigan School of Social Work to speak as part of their Grand Rounds lecture series. Everyone was so lovely, and I was so very honored to be able to give this lecture, as well as to visit a qualitative methods seminar and meet with faculty and students.

My lecture was, rather predictably, about comics-based research. I focused specifically on why CBR is a nimble tool for navigating the difficult, phantasmagoric times we find ourselves in. I talked about art, about feeling, about the Velveteen Rabbit and the Skin Horse and also yarn bombing Birmingham with crocheted tits. And I also talked a little bit about AI because they asked me to. And in a move that should not surprise anyone, I am not a fan of AI. AI is seductive, destructive, deceptive, and disorienting. It is in league with nothing good. Here’s what I said:


You should fight like a dog against AI. I was asked to comment on AI and arts-based scholarship, and while the organizers of this talk may have imagined something slightly more nuanced, here is my comment. There is no morally defensible use of AI. AI is the near enemy of art. I have written elsewhere about the concept of the near enemy:  A near enemy is something that looks the same but is actually a dangerous, damaging opposite. For example, mystery writer Louise Penny (2007) offers the illustrative case of the near enemies, compassion and pity:

“Two emotions that look the same but are actually opposites. The one parades as the other, is mistaken for the other, but one is healthy and the other’s sick, twisted . . . Attachment masquerades as Love, Pity as Compassion . . . Compassion involves empathy. You see the stricken person as an equal. Pity doesn’t. If you pity someone you feel superior . . . so pity is the near enemy of compassion . . . It looks like compassion, acts like compassion, but is actually the opposite of it. And as long as pity’s in place, there’s not room for compassion. It destroys, squeezes out, the nobler emotion” (p. 198).

For example, in a book chapter I wrote about feminized professions and teachers, nice is the near enemy of good, with the pursuit of the appearance of niceness driving out actual goodness that might be beneficial to others. To do good takes courage and often involves conflict and requires challenging both authority and the status quo. Trying to appear “nice” requires none of these. Instead, Nice involves avoiding conflict, supporting existing power structures through obedience and focusing on appearance to such a degree that substance is eventually forgotten. Along with everything real.

Appearing Nice and Doing Good are near enemies in the classical sense, such that when one sees a performance of Nice Girl, one should prick up one’s ears. So also it is with art. AI is the near enemy of art. It may look like art. You might use it like art, but make no mistake, it is only a masquerade. It is the hollow chocolate Easter Bunny. It is to art as pity is to compassion, as nice is to good. It squeezes out the nobler emotion. AI destroys art. It is not a neutral tool. It is the bankruptcy of process and therefore meaning. Because anyone who knows art, and anyone who knows research, knows that its power and provenance is in the process of it. In the integrity of its making. Sure, it might take me ten minutes to draw this picture of a cat, but what you cannot see is the 35 years of work as a professional artist behind the ease and movement and power of those lines. And when you buy the painting, you do not know that beneath the paint is an artist who had to go to a place to create it. In a world that wants you to believe nothing is real, believe this: art is real. It is the best way to create a tangible foothold in the world of the phantasmagoric. A world in which the evildoers and their machine want you to be confused, lose your footing and forget the real.

Some people start whining at this point, saying, “well, AI is a tool that lets everyone make art.” Which is trash. It is a tool that lets everyone eat Styrofoam replicas of food when a real meal lies elsewhere. Everyone here can do comics-based research. You worry that CBR is only available for people who can already do the art. People who already have an MFA. People who already have gallery shows or were in the original cast of Hamilton. This is fantastically untrue. Draw like you are leaving a cute note for your roommates on the fridge. This is real.


And you can quote me on that

Pirie, S. (2025). Comics-based research, art, and near enemies. An invited lecture for the University of Michigan School of Social Work Grand Rounds Series, University of Michigan, October 29.

Also, this post’s featured image is Flay by Titus Kaphar (2019).

And here is the full text of my chapter in that book.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *