Month: December 2025

Guest Lecture at Galway (Or, “Down With the Crusties!”)

Guest Lecture at Galway (Or, “Down With the Crusties!”)

In which I appear quite heroic indeed. I gave a little guest lecture to some wonderful students at the University of Galway and received the best thanks ever. The instructor wrote, “Thank you so much for joining our comics class yesterday! The students were absolutely …

A Semester of Arts-Based Teaching

A Semester of Arts-Based Teaching

This semester I taught three classes that focused on arts-based scholarship. These included The Junior Year Writing students began the semester exploring nonconventional texts at the UMass museum of contemporary art, where they were able to meet the artists of the Over the River Collective …

The Death Game Rides Again

The Death Game Rides Again

A few years ago I wrote a piece about The Death Game in preschool; to make a very long story short, this was an often wild, often somber, sometimes unruly and always ket game that the preschoolers in my field site cooked up as a way to explore the boundaries of children’s spaces. Sometimes the children constructed elaborate funerary landscapes, other times they enacted wildly exaggerated death throes, all the while aware that adults were picking up what they were laying down. My analyses drew heavily from the brilliant work of Rachel Rosen, who is in my mind the foremost writer on children’s death play.

This new piece, Putting Flesh on the Death Game, revisits these data in the form of a social story. As I write in the piece’s text introduction:

I spent nearly every summer of my life with my father’s family in Appalachian Tennessee, in a place called Bulldog Hollow, near the little town of Elizabethton. This meant creek shoes, catching crawdads, watching the big boys kill copperheads, my grandfather’s pipe smoke and lots of time in church. I would sit through the seemingly endless service in my shiny white patent leather shoes and monogrammed gingham dress and then join the other six year olds in the church basement for Sunday school. I remember one Sunday in particular. “Now, what is a parable?” the Sunday School teacher asked us all. “Why, it’s a story!” she exclaimed, “And Jesus taught using stories to put meat on the bones, so everybody could get something good from what he was saying.” Of course I already knew exactly what that was, for my grandmother told parables every day to lyrically impart important ideas to her crowd of multi-aged grandchildren. She was a master of putting meat on the bones.

Stories have always been a part of qualitative research, but only recently have fictions been mobilized as a formal arts-based approach. Patricia Leavy’s 2011 novel, Low Fat Love, is one of the earliest examples of using the novel as a means to represent research in this way. This novel, which is based on ten years of Leavy’s interviews with young women about gender, identity, sexuality and the body, is grounded in that research as well as Leavy’s experiences to “put flesh onto themes captured in Leavy’s research and teaching, as well as fictionalized versions of her own personal experiences. It shows us what arts-based research can look like” (Sleeter, 2024 np). Like a good teaching story, it puts meat on the bones. Other researchers have also used fiction in this way, including Sleeter (2015; 2021), who noted the power of the story as integral to imagining the richness of research in new ways, to “prompt deep reflection in a way that data and theory do not. Stories capture experiences and emotions; my students remembered stories long after forgetting social science data” (Sleeter, 2024 np). As per the above, they enflesh the robust, sturdy bones of the work.

So, when I sought to tell the story of what transpired during my three year ethnography among the preschoolers, I wanted to create a fictional account to put some meat on the bones, but I wanted to represent how social theory can be applied to the world of childhood—in particular, I wanted readers to see how Kristeva’s concept of abjection works (Kristeva, 1982). Further, I wanted to illustrate (literally!) the ways in which the feminization of a profession and the constraints of gendered carework in particular throw the entire carnival of abjection into stark relief. I had written about the taboo play (Pirie, 2017) and about abjection (Pirie, 2021a) before, but a social fiction was needed to “put flesh onto the themes” of what I found, what I learned, and, most importantly, the ways in which theory truly supports deeper understanding of how cherubs become dirty in the feminized carework space. Playing the Death Game is the result. In it, we see the interrelationship between adult identities vis-à-vis gendered goodness in the context of feminized labor and how children are constructed as reservoirs for that goodness. Once children become “improper” so also do the women who care for them, which results in the horror (and rage) of abjection (Jones et al, 2010). Further, particular children are more frequently constructed as soiled, unclean and improper because of their racialized locations, and as these children become more difficult to fold into the adult identity of good, so are they more likely to be pushed out of early childhood spaces in different ways (Pirie, 2021b). Creating The Death Game using CBR helped me apply and understand a theoretical framing for how young children being “naughty” creates a tinder box centered around precarious adult identities, beyond even the notion of the cheeky forbidden, or “ket” (James, 1989). The ethnography of childhood often presents researchers and readers with sticky, unruly data, not unlike Gottlieb’s (2004; 2012) ethnographies of infancy, where the “data” produced by babies appears as cries, leakage and sound. So “feeling” the data via the process of restorying this work contributes directly to my, and the readers’,  understanding the necessary visceralities of thick description in the preschool context.

You can read the rest of the typeset introduction material, the comic social story itself (!) and even some thoughtful little discussion questions at the conclusion in the book itself here.

Pirie, S. C. (2026). Putting flesh on the death game: Reflections on a comics-based social story methodology. In Johnson, A. T. & C. H. Sam (Eds.) Short Stories for Social Research. Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003540564-8