Hooray for ugly bitches!

This was one of those book chapters that was so much fun to write—and something I have been itching to get out there for some time. As many of you know, one of my early areas of scholarship was labor force feminization. I even wrote a book about how I saw a lot of the troubling trends of the alt right reflected in how some young people conceived of the gendered work of teaching, and how teacher educators and others unwittingly (or sometimes very wittingly indeed) reinforced a lot of these ideas. It wasn’t an awesome good news moment, and I felt like Cassandra jumping up and down and screaming at somebody, anybody, to pay attention to white women. That was 2012. But something I reflect on now, over ten years since I wrote the book, is that even though my findings were correct and disturbing (and validated so horrifyingly now) I’m not sure I spent enough time in the field really looking at these young women and constructing them as generously and agentively as they deserved.
So when I did the work on Ugly Bitches, yes, I was talking about art education, but also about how the teachers themselves can be radically affected—and have the capacity to shift and grow—and how we as teachers in higher education need to see their many funds of knowledge and radical potential. My students are mostly young, cis white women, but they are also smart, agentive people who have made strategic choices and are constantly, critically reflecting on those choices and evaluating their own positions of power and vulnerability. Being young right now is very challenging but these young people, mostly white cis women but certainly not all, are doing the work and I can see it how they grapple with art, self, and the idea of being powerful and effective–even if it means being ugly. I love my art education students, and I think it shows through here in their journey and my own. Let’s hear it for the ugly bitches. I’m proud to say I’m one of them.


Pirie, S. C. (2026). Ugly bitches will save your life: Teaching art as method. In H. G. Caplan and Thompson, C. M. (Eds.) Postdevelopmental Approaches to Challenging Myths and Misconceptions in Early Childhood Art, pp. 33-58. Bloomsbury. DOI: 10.5040/9781350539310.ch-2
Also, this chapter tells the amazing story of Mabel the Guinea Pig. You should buy the book so you can find out how we were all radicalized by Mabel. #Mabelforever

